subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Sun, Sep 07 2008 

Published January 21, 2007 12:00 am - WASHINGTON -- Barney Frank, the 14-term Massachusetts congressman who chairs the Financial Services Commi...

Diminishing inequality


The Norman Transcript

WASHINGTON -- Barney Frank, the 14-term Massachusetts congressman who chairs the Financial Services Committee, says it might be useful to "make it a misdemeanor to use metaphors in the discussion of public policy," such as "a rising tide lifts all boats." Against what he considers that too-complacent view of economic growth (the metaphor was John Kennedy's), Frank says: A rising tide is wonderful "if you have a boat."

Frank questions whether market-driven wealth creation is producing more inequality "than is either socially healthy or economically necessary." He favors much more government intervention in the economy to diminish inequality. Sometimes he means equal dependence on government. For example, he wants everyone enrolled in Medicare -- with larger co-payments for higher-income people -- in order to take health care "out of the wage system."

Frank mildly says that Congress should "pay a little more attention" to the seven governors of the Federal Reserve System, all of whom are confirmed by Congress. The Fed, says Frank less mildly, should not be considered "above democracy": "We can debate whether Terri Schiavo's life should be recognized as over" and other fundamental questions of existence, "but God forbid anybody in elected office should talk about whether or not we need a 25-basis point increase" in interest rates. "Somehow that's sacrosanct. No, it isn't. It's public policy."

The late Sen. William Proxmire, a populist Democrat who represented Wisconsin for 32 years, said that all members of Congress should have written on their bathroom mirrors, so it is the first thing they read each day, this: "The Fed is a creature of Congress." Frank says Congress should not intervene in monetary policy ... "unless." By monitoring whether the Fed's governors act as they said they would when they were being confirmed, Congress would be "setting the predicate for intervention if they act otherwise."

He wants the Fed to emphasize full employment as well as protect the currency as a store of value -- restraining inflation. But the Fed's stunning conquest of inflation since the early 1980s is almost a sufficient explanation of subsequent prosperity.

Three years ago, when unemployment was 5.8 percent, Frank outlined his doctrine of "capitalism plus" -- plus a lot of government -- in a House speech, warning that America was at "a major inflection point" where the economy's ability to create wealth is exceeding its ability to create jobs. Today unemployment is 4.5 percent. How low can it go? He answers briskly: It fell to 3.8 percent during the Clinton administration. Could that become normal? And Frank says that when The New York Times wrote that the economy had exceeded its "normal rate of growth" for eleven years, he wrote to the Times wondering whether facts are redefining normality.

Frank may be the most liberal member of Congress. His thinking is what today's liberalism looks like when organized by a first-class mind. He thinks he discerns cultural contradictions of conservatism: Some conservative policies -- free trade, and tax and other policies that (he thinks) widen income inequalities -- undermine support for other conservative policies. When capitalism's "creative destruction," intensified by globalization, churns the labor market and deepens the insecurities of millions of families, conservatives should not be surprised by the collapse of public support for free trade and an immigration policy adequate to the economy's needs.

Frank's solution, "fair trade," is to use the threat of denying access to the American market to force less-developed countries to adopt "minimal standards of civility," meaning more expansive -- more American -- labor rights and environmental protections. This is an economic version of George W. Bush's foreign policy. Bush's Wilsonian goal is "ending tyranny in our world." Frank's trade policy is "Wilsonianism without weapons." Or perhaps it is Johnsonian (Lyndon Johnson): Trade policy should impose semi-Great Society rules on less-developed trading partners, thereby helping the poor in those countries -- and reducing those countries' competitive advantages.

Frank's committee has, he says, "a larger jurisdiction to talk than to legislate." Pay attention to the talk: In it liberalism's interest in diminishing inequality (using government power to regulate the economy's distribution effects) duels with conservatism's emphasis on freedom (incentives by which market forces rationally allocate wealth and opportunity).

Frank says he is fortunate to be "in a profession where a weakness of mine -- a short attention span -- is a strength." In a government with its fingers in far too many pies, legislators must flit from one subject to another. What distinguishes Frank, however, is the coherence -- which is not a synonym for persuasiveness -- of his argument for more government-engineered equality.

George Will writes for the Washington Post Writers Group. His e-mail address is georgewill@washpost.com.



print this story    email this story    comment on this story   

Click to discuss this story with other readers on our forums.

Click here to load this Caspio Bridge DataPage.
Click here to load this Caspio Bridge DataPage.




monster
wheels
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Premier Guide

Find a job! Find a Home! Find a car!

Premium Jobs

Pharmacy Technician Adjunct Instructor
Certified Pharmacy Technician to teach 300+ hr Pharmacy Technician course, Min. 5 yrs exp. preferred as Pharmacy Technic...>MORE

Now Hiring
Culinary Help, Dishwashers, Host, Morning Servers and Bussers,
Must be able to work all shifts
Apply Anytime:<
...>MORE

Secretary Project Coordinator
Secretary Project Coordinator
Needed for a Commercial Const. Comp. Require: Multi Phone Lines,
Basic Office &
...>MORE

Noble Healthcare Center
NEW LPN PAY RATES
$500 Sign On Bonus,
After 6 Months FT Employment
FT Shifts Available
M - F • 3p -
...>MORE

Dishwashers Needed!!
Belmar Golf Club is now hiring full and part- time dishwashers. Great job along side school or second job.
Apply
...>MORE

THERAPIST
Licensed or eligible for supervision. Fax resume w/refs,SS# & Job #09-003 to 632-1976 or mail to :HOPE<...>MORE

Mid-Con Carriers
Class A CDL Driver Needed! Out & Back Runs • Home Weekly!
NEW Petes • Good Benefits!
Starting at 44K • 405-2
...>MORE

Sonic Drive In
Now Hiring
All Positions for All Shifts
Top Pay Available!
Please Call Rachel at 301-4111
or Fax Re
...>MORE

CADC or LADC
Licensed or eligible for supervision. Fax resume w/refs,SS# & Job #09-004 to 632-1976 or mail to :
HO
...>MORE

P/T Administrative Asst. for Pastor
Computer skills with Word, Publisher a must. Good people skills and self starter. Flexible Hours.
Contact Rev. Dave
...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Homes

Horses OK!! Cowboys Too??
NEW 4Bd Mini-Ranchette
Horse Property • Acres • Water Well
$16 Down • $731/Mo
405-217-8600
...>MORE

BIG House on the Prairie
NEW 4Bd/2Bth/2Lv Custom
Acreage with Privacy
EZ Qualify • $22 Down • $677/Mo
405-217-8600
...>MORE

Executive Home site
Build your Estate on these 11.6 Acres at E Lindsey and SE 48th.Beautiful wooded site. Part of Highland Hills. Fenced on...>MORE

FSBO Lake Front House on 6.3 AC’s
1750 SF • 3Bd/2Bth/2CarGranite Ctrs, Spa,
LG Deck • $160K • on Reynold’s Lake
405-664-4188 • 366-6840
...>MORE

English Style • 3200+/- SF
2 Story • Built in the 40’s
Lots of Trees & Character on 2 Acres
$279,000 • FSBO • (580)371-6677
...>MORE

Lease-Option to Buy,
Large Executive Home in W Norman,
Call Bill Tucker O/A
919-1746, Preferred Realty, Inc
...>MORE

Kozy Kottage
3Bd/2Bth/FmRm Custom Kitchen
Gingerbread Like - WOW!
HURRY! • $19 Down • $589/Mo
405-217-8600
...>MORE

NO First, NO Last, NO Kiddin!
Blanchard Schools • NEW
4Bd/2Bth on Acreage, Views N’More
RENT or PURCHASE • $722/Mo
405-217-8600
...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Extras

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2008. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index