The Norman Transcript

Editorials

April 1, 2013

Congress should reconsider proposed update to CFA Act

NORMAN — Congress passed the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act in the early days of the Internet to crack down on malicious hackers, but federal prosecutors have stretched the law since then to apply to computer users who merely violated a website’s terms of service.

Now, the House Judiciary Committee is circulating a proposed update of the act that, instead of fixing its flaws, would enable prosecutors to threaten alleged violators with dramatically bigger penalties. That’s a dangerous step that lawmakers shouldn’t even consider in light of the well-documented misuses of the law.

The 1986 act makes it a crime to gain access to information on a computer in an unauthorized way — for example, by hacking through the passwords protecting a shopping website’s server and copying the credit card numbers stored there. That prohibition applies to both people who aren’t authorized to use the computer and to people who exceed the authority they were granted.

The problem is that the act doesn’t clearly define what it means by exceeding one’s authorization. As a result, some prosecutors have argued — and some judges have agreed — that simply violating a site’s terms of service is equivalent to gaining unauthorized access. The draft circulated by the Judiciary Committee’s staff maintains the sorry status quo, affirming that those who violate terms of service to obtain information from a government website or “sensitive or nonpublic information” from any other site could be prosecuted. As cyber-law expert Orin Kerr observed, “the language would make it a felony to lie about your age on an online dating profile if you intended to contact someone online and ask them personal questions.”

A much better idea is the proposal by Rep. Zoe Lofgren, D-Calif., to narrow the law so that merely violating a site’s terms of service to obtain information would not be a crime. Lofgren’s proposal is backed by numerous online groups and civil libertarians. The committee’s draft, however, reflects the Justice Department’s desire for an even bigger hammer to use against online offenders. Among other things, it would enable prosecutors to bring federal racketeering charges against people accused of two or more violations of the 1986 law.

— Los Angeles Times

For local news and more, subscribe to The Norman Transcript Smart Edition, or our print edition.

1
Text Only | Photo Reprints
Editorials
  • Dancing forward

    The official motto for Mike Fowler’s chairmanship of the Norman Chamber of Commerce is “Moving Norman Forward.” But after Thursday night’s annual banquet, the sub-theme should be, “Let’s Dance, Norman.” More than 500 chamber members and ...

    April 19, 2014

  • Local control or not?

    Oklahoma lawmakers are a fickle bunch when it comes to issues of local control. Sometimes they want it and other times they do not....

    April 19, 2014

  • There’s no need to fix system that’s working

    Lawmaker attempts to alter the way judges are selected are being challenged by the state’s lawyers. More than 1,800 signatures on a state bar association petition urging a “no” vote on Senate Joint Resolution 21 have been gathered in just ...

    April 18, 2014

  • On the side of openness

    Oklahoma Gov. Mary Fallin has been criticized for failing to release emails and other information sought by press outlets who believe it was covered under the state’s Open Records Act. Now, Fallin is coming down on the side of keeping the ...

    April 18, 2014

  • A raise for troopers, but what about others?

    Oklahoma Highway Patrol troopers could see an increase in their paychecks during the state’s next fiscal year, which begins in July....

    April 17, 2014

  • Top honors for NPS

    Top honors keep rolling in for both of Norman’s high schools. The district learned this past week that Norman High School and Norman North High School have been recognized as two of the most rigorous high schools in the country and in the ...

    April 16, 2014

  • Wind power bursting

    There are a few wind generators dotting the Norman skyline, but western and northwestern Oklahoma makes up for the deficit here. An industry group this week said Oklahoma ranks fourth nationally in the amount of wind-generated ...

    April 16, 2014

  • Protect your home from wildfires

    To most people, fuel is what you put into your gas tank. To firefighters, it means something altogether different. To people who make a living putting out fires, fuel is that material that feeds wildfires — and there is an abundance of it ...

    April 12, 2014

  • Let’s toast: Main Street bridge nearly complete

    It was January 2013 when crews began knocking down the Main Street bridge over Interstate 35. The timeline on completion has always been this May. If everything comes together and the weather holds for the next few days, the overpass and ...

    April 11, 2014

  • Yes to Capitol and museum

    Two major spending bills have emerged from the powerful House Appropriations and Budget Committee headed by Norman Rep. Scott Martin. Both are up for passage in the full House of Representatives. We believe both deserve passage....

    April 11, 2014