The Norman Transcript

Editorials

September 22, 2013

Shedding light on NSA’s snooping

NORMAN — In releasing an opinion by a secret court approving the bulk collection of Americans’ telephone records, the director of national intelligence may have thought he would bolster support for the broad program whose existence was revealed by former National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden.

But Judge Claire Eagan’s explanation of the legal justification for the program is unpersuasive, and her suggestion that members of Congress knew the details of the program when they reauthorized the Patriot Act makes a point she may not have intended: that Congress is more likely to approve legislation that intrudes on Americans’ privacy if citizens are kept in the dark.

Eagan, a U.S. district judge from Oklahoma, is one of 11 members of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court. On Aug. 29, she issued an opinion upholding the collection by the NSA of telephone metadata.

Eagan made two points: that the program didn’t violate the 4th Amendment’s ban on unreasonable searches and seizures, and that it was a lawful application of the Patriot Act. Regrettably, her first conclusion is accurate. In 1979, the Supreme Court held that citizens don’t have a reasonable expectation of privacy in information they provide to “third parties” such as a telephone company. We have argued that the court needs to revisit that question.

Much less defensible is the judge’s assertion that the data collection is authorized by a section of the Patriot Act that allows the government to obtain business records “relevant to an authorized investigation” of espionage or terrorism. Eagan concludes that the phone records of virtually every American are “relevant” because the government needs a “broad collection” of data to discern calling patterns that could identify terrorists.

The judge’s trump card is that Congress renewed the Patriot Act in 2011 by healthy margins. She notes that before the votes, documents and briefings were made available “to afford each member full knowledge of the scope of the (Patriot Act provision) and of the underlying legal interpretation” by the court. But whether most members of Congress were aware of the program, their constituents were in the dark.

After the public learned about the program, sentiment shifted on Capitol Hill, and the House came within a handful of votes of curtailing it.

— Los Angeles Times

1
Text Only | Photo Reprints
Editorials
  • State, local jobmarkets look up

    A tight labor market is often a big problem for economic development professionals. They need to be able to promise companies that there are willing workers in the community’s labor pool....

    July 26, 2014

  • Be careful out in the heat

    This week’s triple-digit temperatures are contributing to heat-related illnesses. The state health department’s Injury Prevention Service reminds Oklahomans of the symptoms of heat exhaustion and heat stroke....

    July 25, 2014

  • Get smart on crime

    It’s no secret that prison guards have become the frontline mental health case workers in Oklahoma prisons. Accessing mental health services outside of prison is tough but even harder behind the walls....

    July 25, 2014

  • Quite the resilient bunch

    The people of Moore are a resilient bunch. They’ve bounced back from tornadoes before, but the current renaissance may be the quickest yet. FEMA officials said it would take two years to see some sense of normalcy. That’s hardly the case....

    July 24, 2014

  • A fresh start for VA

    All of us have high hopes for the confirmation and success of Veterans Affairs Secretary nominee Robert McDonald. If confirmed — and most believe he’s a shoe-in — McDonald will take over a paralyzed system of health care that is not ...

    July 24, 2014

  • Call up National Guard

    We’re not sure it will help, but you have to hand it to Texas Gov. Rick Perry. He deployed up to 1,000 Texas National Guard troops to help secure his state’s border with Mexico this week....

    July 23, 2014

  • It’s only getting worse

    Conditions for children in Oklahoma were starting to look up for a few years, according to the annual Kids Count reports. Now we know it wasn’t getting better. The recession was impacting the rest of the country, dropping their scores....

    July 23, 2014

  • Noting a life well lived

    James Garner never intended to be a movie and television star. He just kind of lucked into it, he would tell those who asked. If you have the itch to act, get a good-paying job and spend your free time at your local community theater, he ...

    July 22, 2014

  • Recount that really matters

    Americans have been hearing a lot about Congressional elections, but there’s another one halfway around the globe that will matter far more....

    July 22, 2014

  • Runoffs get no respect

    The Aug. 26 Republican runoff election for the Cleveland County District 3 commissioner post is one of only 18 races on ballots around the state. Only two races are statewide — the Democrat contests for U.S. Senator nominee and state ...

    July 22, 2014