The Norman Transcript


October 6, 2012

A-F grading system: questions and answers



The SDE’s formula does not accurately measure academic growth in students.

What is the effect of this formula for a high-performing district?

Perhaps to best demonstrate the effect is to give an example based on the preliminary grades the SDE has computed of NPS schools: One NPS school deemed High Performing by federal criteria and which has over 90 percent or more of its 300 students tested at Proficient and Advanced on state exams will likely receive a B because of the formula’s heavy weighting of 24 students’ scores who present unique learning challenges and because of its flawed computation for measuring those 24 students’ academic improvement.

Shouldn’t schools be accountable for students with challenges?

Absolutely and they have been, especially since the No Child Left Behind law. However, because the SDE’s new formula doesn’t accurately reflect the academic gains being made by students, the High Performing NPS school referred to in our example will likely receive a B even though its lower performing students are improving academically.

How do the grades not accurately reflect students’ academic growth?

The SDE’s formula for calculating “state average growth” is what a school must meet to earn credit in the formula for its lower performing students making academic gains. However, this average isn’t a true average because the SDE chose to compute it by only using the test scores of students across the state who posted gains from one year’s subject test to the next year, e.g. they did better on the 4th grade reading test than they did on the 3rd grade reading test. Why is this a problem? Most students will perform at grade level and will do about the same on the state subject tests from one grade to the next grade because the tests are designed to measure grade level mastery of the content. However, in computing average academic growth for its formula, the SDE excluded the scores of students who performed the same from one year’s subject tests to the next, as well as excluded the test scores of students who didn’t perform as well on the next year’s subject tests. This inflated the ‘average’ and resulted in most schools across the state receiving lower grades even if their students were improving academically.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
  • honor_roll.jpg Local students make the grade

    Norman Public Schools has released the most recent honor rolls. Click a school to see if you know a student who made the grade.

    View honor rolls for Norman High School | Norman North High School
    Alcott Middle School | Irving Middle School | Longfellow Middle School | Whittier Middle School

    June 10, 2013 1 Photo

  • Norman High student argues his way to the top

    Knowing the ins and outs of an argument that involves complex research is the type of skill one expects a high paid attorney to have not a high school student. Yet debate competitor Nicky Halterman has been arguing his way to the top of ...

    July 30, 2014

  • Grad to serve as delegate at camp

    William Long, 2014 Norman North High School graduate, recently represented Oklahoma as a delegate at the 2014 National Youth Science Camp. Long joined 100 other top high school graduates representing the United States and eight other ...

    July 25, 2014

  • More than 700 to receive clothing, school supplies

    OKLAHOMA CITY — Citizens Caring for Children will host a two-day Back-to-School shopping event for school-aged children in foster care living in Oklahoma, Canadian, Cleveland, Grady, Lincoln, Logan and Pottawatomie counties....

    July 24, 2014

  • Program to fund classroom projects

    U.S. Cellular is donating $1 million to fund teacher classroom projects across the nation, including Oklahoma, through its “Calling All Teachers” program. Last year, the company contributed $500,000 toward educational materials for ...

    July 23, 2014

  • New AP program to begin in Norman

    NORMAN — Norman Public Schools Board of Education learned about Advanced Placement Capstone at a regular board meeting Monday....

    July 22, 2014

  • Noble teacher is state finalist

    Local teacher Roger Clement has been named one of 12 finalists for the 2015 Oklahoma Teacher of the Year award by the Oklahoma State Department of Education. Clement teaches physical science, biology, chemistry and chemistry II at Noble ...

    July 17, 2014

  • MNTC board to consider purchases

    The Moore Norman Technology Center Board of Education will conduct a regular board meeting at 5:30 p.m. today on the Norman campus, 4701 12th Ave. NW, conference room A-200....

    July 17, 2014

  • Principals named for Norman North, Madison Elementary

    The Norman Board of Education announced tonight that it is hiring Dr. Peter Liesenfeld as principal of Norman North High School and Annette Williams as principal of Madison Elementary....

    July 16, 2014

  • Three more local students named National Merit Scholarship winners

    On Monday, the National Merit Scholarship Corporation (NMSC) announced approximately 1,600 additional winners of National Merit Scholarships financed by colleges and universities. Three area students were named National Merit Scholarship ...

    July 15, 2014