The Norman Transcript

Headlines

November 13, 2013

Professor discusses campaign finance

(Continued)

NORMAN —

“The decision in Buckley is somewhat schizophrenic,” Thai said. The decision in Citizens United v. FEC (2010) comes from a century-old argument made by writers like John Milton who said a free marketplace of ideas, including negative speech, brings forth the best ideas.

In Schwarzenegger v. Entertainment Merchants Association, the First Amendment was found to be blind to various types of free speech. Thai said Citizens United evolved from free speech cases like Entertainment Merchants to apply the same free speech principles to campaign financing.

Quoting the Supreme Court, Thai read the Citizens United opinion and said, “The First Amendment does not allow political speech restrictions based on a speaker’s ... identity.”

This ruling makes the free speech of spending money on campaigns: content agnostic, medium agnostic and speaker agnostic. However, Thai said the Citizens United ruling is not as broad as people think.

“It does not green light outside spending of Super Pacs,” he said. “What it does do is enable corporations to contribute.”

Criticisms of the Citizens United case abound. Thai said if campaign finance spending borrows its principles from an economic philosophy of a marketplace of ideas, then problems of those economic principles may permeate campaign finances, as well.

“Just like over concentration problems in the economic market, if you have a lot of money to spend, you can saturate the media market and buy a pretty big megaphone,” Thai said. “He who has the biggest megaphone may not have the best ideas, and the market may become distorted.”

To end his lecture, Thai turned to Bluman v. FEC (2012) to point out further Supreme Court inconsistencies.

“The majority actually believes that the identity of a speaker can’t be ignored,” he said. “In Bluman, the court upheld a lower court decision that bans foreign campaign contributions. The decision was unanimous with no explanation.”

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Headlines
  • Braddy_1. Norman North teen struck by freight train recovering with therapy

    A Norman North teen struck by a freight train in May is on the road to recovery and ready to get back to school after spending most of his summer in a hospital. Harrison Braddy, 16, has been staying busy with rehab and physical therapy ...

    July 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • Storm victims face loan dilemma

    The tornadoes, flooding and hail that struck Oklahoma last year left hundreds of millions of dollars in property damage, causing many home and business owners to seek help in the form of low-interest federal loans....

    July 27, 2014

  • Teen critical after rescue

    A 17-year-old Yukon male was transported to the hospital Sunday after a near drowning incident at Lake Thunderbird in the Party Cove area. Emergency crews responded to the lake after a report of a possible drowning around 5:30 p.m. ...

    July 27, 2014

  • Migrant kids go to Mass

    The services have all the elements of a typical Sunday Mass — singing, scripture, a sermon, prayers, communion and worship....

    July 27, 2014

  • Injury accident reported

    Transcript Staff Emergency crews responded to an injury accident around 10:20 p.m. Sunday in the 1000 block of 80th Avenue Southeast where there were reports of someone pinned. Several reports indicated a vehicle struck a tree causing one ...

    July 28, 2014

  • Photo Slideshow: James Garner through the years

    Photos of James Garner...

    July 27, 2014

  • Prisons expand reach to bring training to more officers

    McALESTER — Joshua Drake once was offered the chance to be a corrections officer but turned it down because he didn’t want to leave his wife and aging parents for six weeks to train hundreds of miles away in El Reno....

    July 27, 2014

  • SWIMMER Aquatic center could serve many community needs

    Michael Yoch could have been the kid with asthma sitting on the sidelines — could have been, but wasn’t. Michael had trouble running because of his asthma, which made it difficult to play soccer and many other sports his friends loved. ...

    July 27, 2014 1 Photo

  • Director leaves decade of memories

    Maureen Dolan is giving up the post as director of St. Joseph’s Early Childhood Development Center, fondly called “St. Joe’s” by the many parents whose pre-school children have spent their weekdays under her care over the past 10 years....

    July 27, 2014

  • Health officials prepare for flu

    OKLAHOMA CITY — Following a flu season in which a record number of Oklahomans died as a result of the virus, state and county health officials say educating the public and general common sense are vital to reducing both the death rate and ...

    July 27, 2014