The Norman Transcript

Letters

February 3, 2013

Hard questions unasked, unanswered

NORMAN — Editor, The Transcript:

The Transcript (“Chamber Hosts Legislative Breakfast,” 1/30/2013) reports that the Norman Chamber of Commerce has endorsed various goals including the following: “Economic development incentives that create and maintain jobs and investment in Oklahoma,” and “funding for the Oklahoma Quick Action Closing Fund to attract new jobs.”

In theory, the idea of making public investments on behalf of the community seems sensible. 

Programs like the Oklahoma Quick Action Closing Fund do “incentivize” businesses. 

Unfortunately, such strategies give businesses an incentive to play communities off against each other to maximize the size of subsidy they receive (i.e., create a bidding war).  The “winner” benefits only if it does not pay more than the additional jobs or investments are worth to the community. 

There is excellent reason to think that communities overpay for businesses – that is what the empirical evidence about economic development incentives indicates.

Firms have the upper hand in negotiating deals (e.g., political clout, more information about their business models, costs, etc.). 

Communities, on the other hand, are not well equipped to accurately assess the costs and benefits of development.  Norman, for instance, does not do fiscal impact analysis of the potential costs/benefits of new development.  (The Norman Economic Development Coalition tries to estimate the job impacts of new businesses, but it uses a simple, static model that always outputs an increase in jobs for any positive input.) 

Offering development incentives is akin to shopping for a car armed with minimal research on the value of a given make/model, and instead basing the purchase decision primarily on the dealer’s input.

Businesses typically employ professional advocates to “sell” projects to communities.  It must be politically difficult for elected officials to say “no” to promises of jobs, even if such promises are unsubstantiated or the jobs cost more than they are worth.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Letters
  • James Garner will be missed

    Editor, The Transcript: Norman native son James Garner was a fine actor on stage, screen and television. I enjoyed the “Maverick” TV series and, in particular, the 1959 episode “The Strange Journey of Jenny Hill” in which the very popular ...

    July 25, 2014

  • Change some lines

    Editor, The Transcript: Looking at how our elected Republican friends are reacting to the refugee children crossing the border and now being housed in Lawton, I have a suggestion. Let’s edit the Christian Bible in several places to reflect ...

    July 21, 2014

  • New health care system demonized

    To the Editor: In October 2013, soon after we were asked to take over management responsibilities at our family business, we were visited by the company’s health insurance agent. She explained that a decision needed to be made regarding ...

    July 21, 2014

  • The longer the wait, the higher the cost

    Editor, The Transcript: Thanks for the great article of July 3 on the Norman chapter of the Citizens Climate Lobby group that recently went to D.C. as citizen lobbyists, working to get a revenue-neutral carbon pollution fee, refunded in ...

    July 20, 2014

  • Natural beauty makes way for parking

    Editor, The Transcript: In support and response to an editorial in The Transcript on June 28 by Pam McIntosh, I am writing this article. In the early ‘70s, many years ago, I lived in what was known as the Sooner Mobile Home Park on South ...

    July 20, 2014

  • Trees do job too well

    Editor, The Transcript: State Rep. Richard Morissette should stick to the concrete and asphalt world, where all of nature has already been killed and people live in fear of living things. Leave our beautiful cedar trees alone....

    July 20, 2014

  • Young people barred from education

    Editor, The Transcript: State universities were created to be the avenue of middle class opportunity in America....

    July 20, 2014

  • Common Core fallacies

    Editor, The Transcript: The article ‘Radioactive’ that discussed Common Core (Transcript, July 14) quotes the fallacy from Republican governors that Common Core is a Federal program; it is not. Many conservatives, especially those labeled ...

    July 19, 2014

  • A pattern is emerging

    Editor, The Transcript: Over the past several weeks, three seemingly unrelated events caught my attention. First, near the end of the legislative session, the House and Senate passed with much fanfare and publicity legislation giving ...

    July 12, 2014

  • Voting for our priorities

    Editor, The Transcript: Ok, let me see if I’ve got this straight. When the federal government ended its program of providing $13-$16 million in surplus equipment each year to fire departments, our state and congressional leaders ...

    July 11, 2014