By Althea Peterson
Transcript Staff Writer
Discussions are evolving on evolution in Oklahoma.
The University of Oklahoma Department of Zoology recently released a statement on evolution, which received unanimous support among its faculty. The statement begins “Evolution is a fact. Evolutionary theory is a cornerstone of biology.” Bill Matthews, director of the department, said the department included all faculty on the discussion before releasing the statement April 19.
“The faculty felt it was important that it showed where we stand on the issue,” Matthews said.
Ola Fincke, zoology professor who drew up the original draft of the statement, said calling evolution a “fact” probably surprises many in the public. However, she said it is the sole explanation for organism creation that can be tested, but has not been proven wrong.
“There is no valid alternative to evolution,” Fincke said.
This statement only comes one month after Oklahoma State University’s department of zoology released a similar statement on zoology, which received support from OSU’s faculty council. Stan Fox, regents professor of zoology at OSU, said their faculty also composed the statement as a group.
“It was in response to the pressure to put intelligent design in the curriculum,” Fox said. “We of course agree with OU that evolution is a cornerstone of biology.”
The difference between the two is a matter of science versus supernatural, said Matt Loven, OSU assistant professor of zoology.
“Among scientists, there is no controversy to evolution,” Loven said. “We believe it is an important part of education. I’m really excited to see that OU finally released a statement. The fact that two major universities agree on this is great.”
However, some do not feel that this news is “great.” Representative Thad Balkman, R-Norman, said the statement seems to exclude any other explanations to organism creation.
“I think it’s disappointing that these people are not open to debating these issues,” Balkman said. “I believe in intelligent design. There are many scientists and physicists who believe in intelligent design. This is orthodoxy.”
When the Oklahoma House considered the “Academic Freedom Act,” Balkman said some incorrectly thought this was an endorsement of teaching ID. He said he is for teaching both evolution and ID.
“I support the teaching of evolution in schools,” Balkman said. “I’m not anti-evolution.”
This is not just a state issue. President George W. Bush spoke on evolution and intelligent design Aug. 1, 2005. He spoke in favor of teaching both equally in science courses.
“Both sides ought to be properly taught… so people can understand what the debate is about,” he said, according to an official transcript of the session. “Part of education is to expose people to different schools of thought. …You’re asking me whether or not people ought to be exposed to different ideas, and the answer is yes.”
Fincke said intelligent design has no place in a science classroom, because it is not science.
“It’s philosophy at best,” Fincke said. “You can believe that, but I believe that God did it via evolution. Teach intelligent design in a philosophy class, or in Sunday school. Intelligent Design has created no new scientific knowledge.”
Vic Hutchison, OU emeritus zoology professor, called OU’s statement “The best I have ever seen on evolution,” but fears that if ID is also taught it will take necessary time away from teaching evolution.
“Science does not, cannot and will not address the matters that are supernatural,” Hutchison said. “Why teach something in science that isn’t science?”
While neither OSU or OU have publicly endorsed the statements from their zoology departments, the OU Faculty Senate has the statement on its agenda for their next meeting. Fox said he hopes state higher education will take a position on the issue as the departments already have.
By Althea Peterson
- Local news
Another ice-cold classic Bedlam in the books
STILLWATER — The first Bedlam football game was held in 1904 at Island Park, now known as Mineral Wells Park, in Guthrie. According to reports, it was a cold, and windy day with the temperatures well below the freezing mark....
Earthquake shakes state
A 4.5 magnitude earthquake shook much of central Oklahoma Saturday afternoon after it struck near Jones, according to the U.S. Geological Survey website....
Sooners Without Borders build water systems on break
More than a dozen University of Oklahoma College of Engineering students and professors gave up their Thanksgiving break to help build water systems in El Salvador. For some students it was their first time out of the country or to be in ...
Noble launches 50 for 50 Campaign
The Noble Public Schools Foundation for Academic Excellence is on a mission. A mission to help the Noble Public School system provide opportunities to enrich and enhance academic excellence for all Noble students. In keeping with its ...
Tom Bishop shares his experiences as Norman’s pharmacist
Come February, Tom Bishop will begin his 41st year as a Norman pharmacist, proprietor of Central Pharmacy at 222 Alameda St. Bishop can look back to the days when the pharmacy was connected by intercom with doctor’s offices and the ...
Physicians honored at holiday dinner
Three physicians were honored at Norman Regional Health System’s annual Medical Staff holiday dinner held this past week at the Embassy Suites Hotel. Honorees were Dr. Lana Nelson, Dr. Farhan Jawed and Dr. Rick McCurdy....
Norman Fire Department receives new Gator ATV from Norman Firehouse Subs
The Norman Fire Department received a donation Tuesday from the Firehouse Subs Public Safety Foundation in the form of an All-Terrain Vehicle. Fire Chief James Fullingim started up the engine to the fire department’s new Gator ATV and ...
Backwoods Norman offers outdoors gifts
If you want to find the perfect gift, follow what brings your loved one bliss. While everyone else is fighting through crowds at big-box stores to get the latest X-Box or Play Station, shoppers who think outside the box can avoid the ...
Christmas Expressions spreads Christmas cheer yearround on West Lindsey Street
Despite its name, Christmas Expression, a locally owned and operated gift gallery of traditional and whimsy merchandise isn’t just about Christmas, according to owner Kathy Merkel-Cox. Well, except maybe at Christmas time. It’s the time ...
Ready for Computer Science Education Week?
The Hour of Code is coming. It cannot be stopped. Resistance is futile. You may even decide to happily become assimilated....
- More Local news Headlines
- Another ice-cold classic Bedlam in the books