Transcript Staff Writer
Historians often judge presidents differently than their contemporary public, and presidents would do well to learn from history, presidential historian Michael Beschloss told University of Oklahoma students Monday evening.
He and OU President David Boren led an informal discussion with about 100 OU students at the Fred Jones Jr. Museum of Art, 555 Elm Ave.
One of the key roles of a historian is to hold current presidents accountable not to repeat history's mistakes, Beschloss said.
"If you're making mistakes, make sure they're your own mistakes," he said.
A President's Associates dinner and keynote address featuring Beschloss followed the discussion. At the dinner, he spoke of the important role of courage in presidencies, most notably that of George Washington, Abraham Lincoln, Harry Truman and John Kennedy.
Beschloss is the author of eight books, his most recent the New York Times best seller "The Conquerors: Roosevelt, Truman and the Destruction of Hitler's Germany, 1941-1945," and this year's "Presidential Courage: Brave Leaders and How They Changed America, 1789-1989."
Beschloss serves as NBC News presidential historian and appears regularly on NBC and PBS programs.
He is an alumnus of Williams College and also holds an advanced degree from the Harvard Business School. He has been a historian on the Smithsonian Institution staff; a senior associate member at Oxford University, England; and a senior Fellow of the Annenberg Foundation in Washington, D.C. He holds honorary doctorates from Williams College, St. Mary's College in Maryland, and Lafayette College.
Despite such distinction, Beschloss seems to excel at making history accessible to a broad audience, Boren said.
Beschloss admitted it's easier to write about history than current events, primarily because there is so much more perspective and information available later.
For example, at the time Dwight Eisenhower was president, the public thought he was weak and ineffective. Years later, when government documents were unclassified, historians discovered Eisenhower had diffused many dangerous situations based on classified intelligence.
One student brought up similar arguments when Beschloss asked students if they thought President George W. Bush would be viewed by historians as a success or a failure.
The student said no one can really know until they know the intelligence Bush knows.
Beschloss said historians often judge war presidents by how they brought the U.S. into war. If they were honest, as Franklin D. Roosevelt was, then historians laud them, he said. If they were dishonest, as Lyndon B. Johnson was, historians crucify them, he said.
Boren said he thought Bush pushed for an Iraq invasion because he wanted to finish what his father started.
But he told the American public they were going in for weapons of mass destruction, Beschloss said. If he really believed that, history will understand, he said. But if he only used that as a pretext, historians will judge him.
"Only President Bush knows that, and that's why we have to wait 30 or 40 years," Beschloss said.
Beschloss described what he considered presidential courage, using examples of Lincoln and Franklin D. Roosevelt.
Both were seeking reelection and advisors told them to change policies they believed in. Roosevelt stuck with his campaign of national defense, but convinced the public it was necessary. Lincoln eventually stood by his emancipation proclamation.
"He flirted with doing the wrong thing and was too great a man to do it," Beschloss said of Lincoln.
Beschloss admitted he could be biased, because he grew up in Illinois where Lincoln is a saint.
When asked by Boren who the greatest president was, Beschloss said he's changed his mind after recent study.
Washington is neck and neck with Lincoln for greatest president, if not a bit better, he said.
"So much of this presidency has to do with the precedents Washington set," he said.
Boren agreed with Beschloss' judgment. Boren said he recently read the foreign policies of Washington and wished more people adhered to them.
John Adams, who learned foreign policy from Washington, said something that applies to the U.S. war today, Beschloss said.
"Great is the guilt of an unnecessary war," he quoted.
"Let us hope a historian in the future doesn't use that to describe Iraq," Beschloss said.
If this conversation had happened in 2000, Beschloss said he would have said Vietnam was so painful that the country has learned lessons it will always remember. Now the same mistakes are being made, he said.
"It is supremely heartbreaking and depressing for me in my profession," he said. "... We have not learned those lessons and it makes me think people in my profession are not doing their job."
After the dinner, Beschloss answered a question about what future historians would use to write presidential history if the first advice from a presidential lawyer is to not put anything in writing.
"This is going to be a problem," he said.
Julianna Parker 366-3550 email@example.com
Transcript Staff Writer
- Local news
J.D. McCarty Center dance group helps kids express themselves
They giggle, they glide, they spin and they shine....
’89er Day Parade marshal chosen
Al Loeffelholz Jr., a longtime Norman banker and the grandson of a German immigrant who staked a claim in the Oklahoma Land Run of 1889, has been selected as this year’s ’89’er Day parade grand marshal, the organizing committee announced ...
Students have a ball at competition
Serious but excited students calculated carefully while concentrating on the exact set of commands that would get their robot to lightly place a cluster of doll-size hangers on a rack. If the robot missed its mark, the students would try ...
NPS to host job fair
Norman Public Schools will host its annual Teacher Job Fair from 3 to 5:30 p.m. March 27 at the Nancy O’Brian Center for Performing Arts at Norman North High School, 1809 Stubbeman Ave....
NRHS offers free at-home colorectal cancer screening
March is National Colorectal Cancer Awareness Month. This cancer is the second leading cause of death in the United States, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Screening is an important step in diagnosing and ...
Tornado season is around the corner
With warmer weather on the horizon, now is a great time to get prepared for turbulent spring weather. Whether you have lived in Oklahoma your entire life or are new to the area, one thing is for certain — storm season must be taken ...
Norman Emergency Management bowls for weather radios
Clack went the pins loudly as they fell over in one lane and then another. A full-house, bowling teams had a great time no matter if it was strikes or gutters at the Norman Emergency Management fundraiser on Saturday. Organizations ...
Helmets in schools ease fears as storm season approaches in Moore
Less than a year ago Jennifer Brumley’s son TJ was dug out of a pile of rubble that used to be his classroom at Briarwood Elementary. The May 20 tornados in Oklahoma destroyed homes and took lives demolishing Briarwood and Plaza Towers ...
’89er Day Parade set for April 12
Round up the wagons and get into gear as you head to Norman’s ’89er Day Parade, scheduled for 10 a.m. April 12 in downtown Norman. The parade, commemorating the day in 1889 that Oklahoma was opened for settlement, will begin at Main ...
Economic Summit to feature Secretary of Commerce
The Norman Economic Development Coalition will host its 2014 Economic Summit Thursday at the Embassy Suites in Norman featuring keynote speaker Secretary of Commerce Larry Parman. In addition to Parman, several local leaders will speak at ...
- More Local news Headlines
- J.D. McCarty Center dance group helps kids express themselves