The Norman Transcript

Local news

March 19, 2009

Court grants judgment to Ashton Grove homeowners

The developers of the exclusive Ashton Grove subdivision in northwest Norman have been ordered to reimburse overcharged homeowners and reconstruct fences, gates and landscaping.

The action, valued by an attorney at more than $3 million, comes three years after a group of homeowners filed a lawsuit alleging the out-of-state developers failed to deliver on promises made to them.

Cleveland County District Judge Tom Lucas signed the judgment March 13. Ashton Grove is near 48th Avenue NW and Rock Creek Road. The plaintiffs include OU football coach Bob Stoops and his wife, Carol, several Norman physicians, developers and others.

Court records showed the lawsuit was filed Feb. 24, 2006, in Cleveland County District Court against Ashton Grove, Ashton Grove Master Association, Ashton Grove Estates Section I Community, William Dow Hamm III, William Dow Ham Jr. and Jonathan H. Brinsden. Brinsden later was dismissed from the lawsuit.

According to the lawsuit, William Dow Hamm Jr. owns Ashton Grove, L.C. His son, William Dow Hamm III controls Hamm Corporation, and the corporation manages Ashton Grove.

Norman attorney Bob Dill represented the plaintiffs named in the lawsuit. The plaintiffs are all homeowners in Ashton Grove.

"The court is granting judgment on various contract-based claims," Dill said.

He said the judgment for plaintiff found the defendants were in fiduciary relationship with the plaintiffs and they breached the relationship. The court is enforcing contracts.

"The value of those improvements the court is ordering to be made is roughly $3.2 million," Dill said.

Dill said the developers failed to build the type of fencing that was obligated in the contract and they failed to build fencing they promised to install.

"The entry gates have been a significant issue from the beginning," Dill said. "He did not build what he should have built."

The attorney also said there was an allegation that the developer had overcharged the assessments against the homeowners. The court has ordered those who were overcharged to be reimbursed.

Dill said the developers have to start construction within 45 days of the judgment.

"It is clearly a judgment for the plaintiffs and grants a relief what the plaintiffs sought and the judgment is as it says as a judgment for plaintiffs on all claims," Dill said.

Norman attorney David Morse represents Ashton Grove, L.C. Contacted late Wednesday, Morse said he had no comment about the Ashton Grove judgment.

Meghan McCormick 366-3539

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Local news
  • N7 Sooners come together to serve Native American youth

    Whitney Wofford has faced some tough competition as a part of the Oklahoma tennis team. However, on Wednesday, Wofford may have taken on her biggest and most rewarding competition yet at the Sooners For N7 event at the Oklahoma football ...

    April 10, 2014 3 Photos

  • Chamber Banquet During annual banquet, Chamber of Commerce promotes moving Norman forward

    Amidst the backdrop of music, dancing, dinner and fellowship, business leader Mike Fowler announced that the time for a quality-of-life initiative in Norman has come. As incoming Norman Chamber of Commerce board chairman, Fowler and ...

    April 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • Symposium speaker Paul Polik: Commerce can help and bring millions out of poverty

    How to harness the power of commerce to address social and environmental challenges in sustainable ways was the topic of discussion at the University of Oklahoma Center for the Creation of Economic Wealth’s fourth annual Social ...

    April 18, 2014

  • Amber waves turn gray as farms lose younger generation

    OKLAHOMA CITY — Jerry Pfeiffer was thrilled when his son, Kelsey, 25, announced plans to return to the family’s farm in Orlando....

    April 18, 2014

  • Postal retiree luncheon set

    A postal retiree luncheon will be 11:30 a.m. Monday at Golden Corral Buffet and Grill, 123 N. Interstate Drive in Norman. Diners will meet in the lobby. For more information, call Joyce Carle at 872-5157....

    April 18, 2014

  • Flapjack fundraiser set

    The Apple Gold Group, a franchisee of Applebee’s Neighborhood Grill and Bar, will partner with the Global Outreach Team at Go Church to host a Flapjack Fundraiser on April 26. Proceeds raised will be used by team members to purchase ...

    April 18, 2014

  • OU Hornsemble goes to the movies

    The OU Hornsemble will present a concert of music from the cinema at 6 p.m. April 27 in the Paul F. Sharp Concert Hall. Billed as “Movie-Time Music,” the ensemble will present a wide variety of cinematic music from the 1940s to the ...

    April 18, 2014

  • Woman bound over for trial

    A Slaughterville woman facing a manslaughter charge after the death of an 8-year-old child was bound over for trial this week after a preliminary hearing in Cleveland County District Court. Kimberly Dawn Wenthold, 29, was charged in ...

    April 18, 2014

  • MNTC campaign focuses on dangers of texting while driving

    Students enrolled in Moore Norman Technology Center’s Career Exploration Education class are taking a class project that they feel strongly about to an involved level within their community. They are raising awareness among their high ...

    April 18, 2014

  • Fighting to rid world of polio

    A small crutch leaned against a podium inside an Oklahoma Memorial Union room Wednesday evening. It was a prop, retrieved and held aloft by Shawn Arnold as he described his early battle with polio....

    April 18, 2014