subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Sat, Nov 07 2009 

Resources

print this story   Print this story
  Post to del.icio.us

Published January 24, 2008 11:23 pm - Transcript Staff Writer
The Supreme Court is the "border guard" of the law, protecting the line between civi...


Supreme Court is border guard, lightning rod, Breyer says


The Norman Transcript

Transcript Staff Writer

The Supreme Court is the "border guard" of the law, protecting the line between civil liberties and security, Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer told University of Oklahoma students, faculty and staff at the OU College of Law Thursday afternoon.

Breyer spoke about the role of the U.S. Supreme Court and how that role has been established historically as part of the sixth annual Henry Family Lecture in Jurisprudence. Breyer is in town this week to take part in the investiture ceremony of Judge Robert Henry, who will be sworn in as Chief Judge of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit 1:30 p.m. today in the Reynolds Performing Arts Center on OU's campus.

Breyer told a full courtroom that the constitution has been a question since it was written. Judges at that time debated how it would be interpreted and who would have the final say. Breyer said he has asked himself that question for years, and still doesn't know an answer.

"I'll do my best to summarize what, say, a few years of experience as a judge has taught me about the answer," Breyer said at the beginning of his lecture.

Only a few years after the United States was founded, the Supreme Court decided it would be the final say in what was constitutional. The decision came easily, but it has been tested over the years. How does a body without the power of the purse or the sword enforce its judgments, Breyer asked.

Over the years, U.S. citizens have gradually accepted this authority, Breyer said.

That's not to say there haven't been problems, though. When the Supreme Court decided a case in favor of the Cherokee Tribe, the state of Georgia still wouldn't let the tribe have its land. Through fake treaties and the like, President Andrew Jackson sent in the military to force the Cherokees out of Georgia and into Oklahoma on the famous Trail of Tears.

Later, however, when the Supreme Court decided public schools needed to integrate, the governor of Arkansas wouldn't obey. But in that instance, President Dwight Eisenhower called in the 101st Airborne and forced integration.

Now there is little question whether the Supreme Court has the final say in the law. For example, in the case of Bush v. Gore in 2000, no one questioned that what the Supreme Court decided was the final word.

"The day after that came down, people said, 'OK, we disagree with that,' ... but (there was) virtually no difference of opinion about what should be done. We'll follow it," Breyer said.

So the Supreme Court's job has been determined, but that doesn't mean the job is easy, Breyer said.

"The constitution is meant to be a workable, democratic document," Breyer said. Justices should look at the constitution's values, but then the intent must be hashed out in individual judgments, he said.

Breyer described Supreme Court justices as "border patrol," given the job of striking a balance between protection of individual liberties and national security. One such difficult example, he said, is the case of rights for prisoners of Guantanamo Bay. It raises hard challenges, but the point is that everyone's trying to work out all the questions it raises, Breyer said.

The Supreme Court must strike a fine balance, he said. It has to have enough independence that it can carry out its job, so that citizens can be confident that decisions were arrived at impartially. That gives people the confidence to obey the Supreme Court's decision even if they don't agree.



print this story    email this story   






autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide

Find a job! Find a Home! Find a car!

Premium Jobs

TOP PAY &
EXCELLENT
BENEFITS

Orientation at a
Comprehensible Pace!

Fulltime - Shawnee!

...>MORE

RECOVERY SUPPORT
SPECIALIST
RSS certification w/Okla Dept of Mental Health req, for busy medication clinic. Req valid OK drivers lic
...>MORE

THERAPIST
Licensed or eligible for supervision. Fax resume w/refs,SS# & Job #09-038 to 632-1976 or mail to :HOPE,...>MORE

Experienced Phone Rep
Are you GREAT on the phone?
Looking for one exp. phone rep.
to set appts.for est. Norman
Hm. Improvemen
...>MORE

LPN or RN needed for a fast paced
clinic in Norman. Clinic & triage
experience required. Apply online www.mcbrideclinic.com or
fax resume to
...>MORE

Ross Health Care
Sales Rep
Excellent Pay & Benefits
Call 224-5659
FAX 224-4790
employment@rosshc.com
...>MORE

See all ads

Premium Homes

See all ads

Premium Extras

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index