NORMAN — Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor made a reasonable decision when, on New Year’s Eve, she temporarily blocked implementation of the Affordable Care Act’s contraception coverage mandate in a case brought by a religious order of nuns that operates homes for the poor and elderly in Catonsville, Md., and elsewhere. It certainly doesn’t hurt to wait a few days and hear the government’s argument for immediate implementation. But the 11th hour drama doesn’t change the fact that the contraceptive coverage requirement is good policy, and the mechanism for groups like the Little Sisters of the Poor to avoid violating their religious tenets is reasonable.
Birth-control pills are often used for medical reasons that have nothing to do with preventing pregnancy. It would make no sense for women who use them, for example, to treat endometriosis to be forced to pay more for them than another drug. Moreover, the cost of unplanned pregnancy on society as a whole and the health-care system in particular is enormous. Two years ago, the Guttmacher Institute, which advocates for reproductive health and rights, estimated that the cost to taxpayers was more than $11 billion annually. Making birth control as readily available as possible is unquestionably a good investment for the health-care system. That’s why the Institute of Medicine recommended that it be included in the preventive care coverage of the Affordable Care Act in the first place.
Religious employers like churches are exempt from the contraceptive coverage requirement, and they always have been. For-profit companies whose owners object on religious grounds to contraception are not exempt, though that issue is headed for the Supreme Court via a pair of unrelated lawsuits. Non-profits that are affiliated with religious institutions fall into a third category that allows an avenue for avoiding the requirement while still giving lay employees access to birth control.
Last month, U.S. District Judge William J. Martinez agreed with the nuns that they were a religious organization under the act even though they are not a church. Based on the group’s history and mission, he said, all they had to do to avoid the substantial penalties the government levies against employers who violate the law was fill out and submit a form to the group administering their employee health care plan. The form amounts to self-certification that “on account of religious objections, the organization opposes providing coverage for some or all of any contraceptive services that would otherwise be required to be covered; the organization is organized and operates as a nonprofit entity; and the organization holds itself out as a religious organization.”
That, presumably, should not be offensive to the nuns’ religious beliefs; rather, it affirms them. What they seem to be objecting to is that the form also includes instructions for how the health plan administrator should process claims for contraceptive services to ensure the Little Sisters are not involved in paperwork or payment for them. Since the nuns’ health plan administrator, Christian Brothers Services, another Catholic charitable group, says it has no intention of providing contraceptive coverage, that would not seem to be a problem. As Judge Martinez put it, the nuns’ continued objection “ignores the factual and legal realities of the case.”
Fnding the balance between protecting the beliefs of organizations like the Little Sisters and those of its employees is tricky, and the nuns’ contention that they faced an impossible choice between committing what they see as a sin or paying hefty fines should not be taken lightly. For that reason, Justice Sotomayor’s grant of a reprieve at least until the government can respond on Friday makes sense. But it doesn’t mean the nuns will or should ultimately prevail. One of the consequences of living in a pluralistic democracy rather than a theocracy is that faith groups must accept that they will be touched in some way by beliefs of which they disapprove.
Breaking news, severe weather alerts, AMBER alerts, sports scores from The Norman Transcript are available as text messages right to your phone or mobile device. You decide which type of alerts you want to receive. Find out more or to signup, click here.