The Norman Transcript


July 6, 2014

Justices put mistaken faith in case ruling

NORMAN — The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that for some businesses, religious life begins at incorporation.

With a 5-4 split vote, the high court said that closely held for-profit companies could invoke First Amendment religious freedom to avoid paying for four types of contraception under the Affordable Care Act.

The dissenting justices marveled at the breadth of legal implications and religious invocations this interpretation can be expected to invite.

Lower courts had said the religious liberties defense by Hobby Lobby Stores and Conestoga Wood Specialties did not apply to companies simply in business to make money.

The court majority said that flies in the face of modern corporate law, and the rights that accrue to closely held companies with limited stock owned by a small number of people. That includes, but is not limited to, family-owned companies.

This was about health care, and a woman’s right to all elements of that coverage and protection, including reproductive health care.

This Taliban-light ruling targets females by letting employers’ religious values dictate what is right and proper for their female employees’ health care — this, but not that.

The majority opinion said the ruling does not provide a shield for employers who cloak illegal discrimination as a religious practice.

The minority hardly found any comfort in that statement. The invocation of religious offense is a litany only limited by the imagination of defense attorneys.

In this case, the attorneys for the craft stores and cabinetmakers bolstered their religious argument with their interpretation that intrauterine devices and morning-after pills constituted abortion.

If, as the court ruling suggests, the government could pay for contraception, why stop there? Is this a sly invitation for a Medicare-like single-payer system? That is as improbable as Congress agreeing to expand birth-control coverage.

When the court talks about moving ahead without imposing a substantial burden on the exercise of religion, it is inviting ever more creative claims of violations.

This case is an insult to women, and personal religious liberty. How will this license to impose one’s religious beliefs on others be applied next?

Breaking news, severe weather alerts, AMBER alerts, sports scores from The Norman Transcript are available as text messages right to your phone or mobile device. You decide which type of alerts you want to receive. Find out more or to signup, click here.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
  • State, local jobmarkets look up

    A tight labor market is often a big problem for economic development professionals. They need to be able to promise companies that there are willing workers in the community’s labor pool....

    July 26, 2014

  • Keeping the war buried

    International outrage over the downing of a Malaysian passenger plane over Ukraine on July 17 does not appear to have affected either the actions of pro-Russia forces in that country or the material support Russia is offering the rebels. ...

    July 26, 2014

  • Gaza’s victims: civilians and peace

    After more than two weeks of fighting between Hamas and Israel, there is no question which side has the upper hand. Thursday’s strike on a U.N.-run school for Palestinian children increased the Palestinian death toll to more than 760. By ...

    July 26, 2014

  • Be careful out in the heat

    This week’s triple-digit temperatures are contributing to heat-related illnesses. The state health department’s Injury Prevention Service reminds Oklahomans of the symptoms of heat exhaustion and heat stroke....

    July 25, 2014

  • Get smart on crime

    It’s no secret that prison guards have become the frontline mental health case workers in Oklahoma prisons. Accessing mental health services outside of prison is tough but even harder behind the walls....

    July 25, 2014

  • James Garner will be missed

    Editor, The Transcript: Norman native son James Garner was a fine actor on stage, screen and television. I enjoyed the “Maverick” TV series and, in particular, the 1959 episode “The Strange Journey of Jenny Hill” in which the very popular ...

    July 25, 2014

  • Quite the resilient bunch

    The people of Moore are a resilient bunch. They’ve bounced back from tornadoes before, but the current renaissance may be the quickest yet. FEMA officials said it would take two years to see some sense of normalcy. That’s hardly the case....

    July 24, 2014

  • A fresh start for VA

    All of us have high hopes for the confirmation and success of Veterans Affairs Secretary nominee Robert McDonald. If confirmed — and most believe he’s a shoe-in — McDonald will take over a paralyzed system of health care that is not ...

    July 24, 2014

  • Call up National Guard

    We’re not sure it will help, but you have to hand it to Texas Gov. Rick Perry. He deployed up to 1,000 Texas National Guard troops to help secure his state’s border with Mexico this week....

    July 23, 2014

  • It’s only getting worse

    Conditions for children in Oklahoma were starting to look up for a few years, according to the annual Kids Count reports. Now we know it wasn’t getting better. The recession was impacting the rest of the country, dropping their scores....

    July 23, 2014