The Norman Transcript

Opinion

May 1, 2013

Does judicial independence matter to us?

NORMAN — “The law makes a promise — neutrality. If the promise gets broken, the law as we know it ceases to exist.’’

— Supreme Court Justice Anthony M. Kennedy

Judicial independence is a simple concept. It means that judges decide cases fairly and impartially, relying only on the facts and the law.

Although all judges do not reason alike or necessarily reach the same decision, decisions should be based on the evidence and the law, not on public opinion polls, personal whim, prejudice, fear or interference from the legislative or executive branches or from private citizens or groups. See, it really is an easy concept, right?

Judicial independence has been a core political value in the United States since before the drafting of our Constitution. Alexander Hamilton, in urging ratification of the constitution of the United States, took as obvious the need for a “steady, upright and impartial administration of the laws by a judiciary of firmness and independence.”

“‘Liberty,’ he said, ‘would have everything to fear from (the judiciary’s) union with the legislature or the executive.’” — The Federalist: No. 78

The judicial branch was established in the U.S. Constitution as a co-equal third branch of our government. The primary purposes of the judicial branch are to solve disputes by making fair and impartial decisions based upon facts, uphold the rule of law and protect our rights.

Public confidence in a fair court system is as necessary for our democracy to operate effectively as are fairly elected executives and legislators.

Because of this important function, judicial independence is one of those laudable virtues that is praised on Law Day.

However, it is often resented when practiced. Since judges must often decide sensitive issues, virtually certain to displease at least half of the participants, that resentment often erupts into attacks that can be politically explosive. This circumstance is nothing new.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Opinion
  • Dancing forward

    The official motto for Mike Fowler’s chairmanship of the Norman Chamber of Commerce is “Moving Norman Forward.” But after Thursday night’s annual banquet, the sub-theme should be, “Let’s Dance, Norman.” More than 500 chamber members and ...

    April 19, 2014

  • NRA members need to step up

    Please, Mr. Bloomberg, leave the checkbook open, but step away from the podium. Your efforts to curb gun violence and improve safety are notable. The National Rifle Association thanks you....

    April 19, 2014

  • Local control or not?

    Oklahoma lawmakers are a fickle bunch when it comes to issues of local control. Sometimes they want it and other times they do not....

    April 19, 2014

  • Norman should act wisely

    Editor, The Transcript: The fact that the city of Norman sells water for oil/gas drilling (or any other purpose) for less than half what they pay Oklahoma City when buying water, and while Norman residents are on rationing, is an act of ...

    April 18, 2014

  • There’s no need to fix system that’s working

    Lawmaker attempts to alter the way judges are selected are being challenged by the state’s lawyers. More than 1,800 signatures on a state bar association petition urging a “no” vote on Senate Joint Resolution 21 have been gathered in just ...

    April 18, 2014

  • On the side of openness

    Oklahoma Gov. Mary Fallin has been criticized for failing to release emails and other information sought by press outlets who believe it was covered under the state’s Open Records Act. Now, Fallin is coming down on the side of keeping the ...

    April 18, 2014

  • A raise for troopers, but what about others?

    Oklahoma Highway Patrol troopers could see an increase in their paychecks during the state’s next fiscal year, which begins in July....

    April 17, 2014

  • Fallin should help residents

    Editor, The Transcript: I see this week that our empty skirt of a governor asked the federal government (small business administration) for much money. She is concerned about the suffering of the business owners in Lexington and Purcell ...

    April 17, 2014

  • Top honors for NPS

    Top honors keep rolling in for both of Norman’s high schools. The district learned this past week that Norman High School and Norman North High School have been recognized as two of the most rigorous high schools in the country and in the ...

    April 16, 2014

  • Wind power bursting

    There are a few wind generators dotting the Norman skyline, but western and northwestern Oklahoma makes up for the deficit here. An industry group this week said Oklahoma ranks fourth nationally in the amount of wind-generated ...

    April 16, 2014