The Norman Transcript

Opinion

October 28, 2013

Compromise is the answer

NORMAN — Tom Horton and Doug Parker, the normally tight-lipped top executives of American Airlines and US Airways, recently floated the idea that they would be open to mediation or an out-of-court agreement to resolve the federal lawsuit against their proposed airline merger.

We’re listening, and we hope the Justice Department is listening, too.

The suggestion, made during a meeting with the editorial board last week, is on the right path to avert a high-risk showdown at trial next month. Courtrooms are risky places; even a win can be a loss. Mediation would give the Justice Department and the airlines a reasonable opportunity to find points of agreement that they would not find during a heated court battle.

We’re not the only ones worried about where this is heading. Mayors in Dallas, Fort Worth, Phoenix, Charlotte, Miami-Dade County, Philadelphia and Chicago co-authored a letter dated Wednesday that cites benefits of the merger for their communities and urges the federal government to let the plan go forward.

A negotiated agreement is the best resolution for the airlines, consumers and the thousands of North Texans whose jobs are linked to a prosperous American Airlines. Not to mention that the merger would be a win for free-market principles.

Just a few months ago, American was in bankruptcy and roiled in ugly fights with its labor unions. Although US Airways didn’t have similar internal drama, it needed a partner to remain relevant in an increasingly competitive industry. American’s emergence from bankruptcy and planned merger with US Airways would solve each airline’s problems. Instead, the Justice Department stepped in.

The department contends that the proposed merger is bad for consumers because it would result in fewer route choices and higher fares. What the government seems to have forgotten is that the airline industry is globally competitive — and airlines have to exist before they can compete. Airline history is littered with once-popular carriers that became too small or too weak to survive.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Opinion
  • Repairs still needed

    Lawmakers once again kicked the can down the road on making needed repairs to the state Capitol. By a 62-34 vote, they turned down a Senate-approved plan to authorize up to $160 million in bonds to repair the nearly century-old building....

    April 24, 2014

  • Health care needs have reached critical stage

    Once again, the Republican-led Oklahoma legislators are leaving Oklahoma’s neediest in the dust with their proposed 2014-2015 budget. Studies by the Oklahoma Health Care Authority and the Oklahoma Department of Mental Health and Substance ...

    April 24, 2014

  • Can’t have it both ways

    Local sheriff Joe Lester wasn’t among the state sheriffs and lawmakers protesting the removal of state prisoners from county jails this week. The sheriffs, some of whom have protested by having too many state prisoners in their ...

    April 24, 2014

  • Help for rural America

    A drive through rural parts of the Southwest can be depressing. For sale and for rent signs are prevalent. Businesses along main streets have closed. Unless they are close to a major interstate highway, many communities are in decline....

    April 23, 2014

  • Embarrassment to Oklahoma, again

    The standardized testing that was halted in local schools Monday is another embarrassment to the state. The same thing happened a year ago and Oklahoma gave them another chance....

    April 23, 2014

  • Time to move on; exit of Sebelius is right choice

    From the moment it became obvious that healthcare.gov wasn’t working, Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius became damaged goods for the White House....

    April 23, 2014

  • Happy birthday to us

    We don’t expect any cake and that many candles might be dangerous but today is the unofficial 125th birthday of Norman....

    April 22, 2014

  • Hero of Haarlem … for common good

    “Trudging stoutly along by the canal,” as the story goes, the 8-year-old son of a Dutch sluicer was returning home from delivering cakes to a blind man. Humming as he passed the dikes, he noticed that recent rains had made his father’s job ...

    April 22, 2014

  • Hate without end

    The news that a former grand dragon of the Ku Klux Klan is suspected of shooting and killing three people near Jewish community centers in Kansas seems at first glance like a disparaged past flaring briefly into the present. Americans like ...

    April 21, 2014

  • Reform is necessary

    Editor, The Transcript: Last year, the legislature passed laws reforming the Oklahoma Department of Veterans Affairs, which was a good start, but more is needed. Recent media reports have revealed that the ODVA employs M.D. and D.O. ...

    April 20, 2014