The Norman Transcript

April 15, 2013

States line up in favor of federal adoption law

By Meg Kinnard
The Associated Press

COLUMBIA, S.C. — The U.S. Supreme Court this week will hear a family challenge to longstanding federal law on the adoption of Native American children, with several states, tribes and welfare groups lining up to support the current rules.

The case involves a South Carolina couple fighting for custody of their adopted daughter who, after a court battle, was returned to her biological father in Oklahoma.

At issue is the Indian Child Welfare Act, a federal law that gives tribes and relatives a say in decisions affecting children with Native American heritage. Passed in 1978, the act gives the tribe and relatives a say in decisions affecting the child.

Matt and Melanie Capobianco adopted a baby several years ago, but the girl’s father — a member of the Cherokee Nation — argued that the child’s mother gave her up without his consent. The state’s highest court sided with him, and she was returned to Oklahoma.

When Dusten Brown challenged the Capobiancos’ adoption, he said federal law favored the girl living with him and growing up learning tribal traditions. A South Carolina court agreed with Brown, who took the girl — named Veronica, and now age 3 — back to Oklahoma in 2011.

Appealing to the state Supreme Court, the Capobiancos said they had bonded with Veronica and argued that removing her was detrimental to her development. But justices sided with Brown last summer, saying in an emotional opinion that, while the Capobiancos were “ideal parents,” federal law requires that custodial preference be given to the child’s Native American parent.

For local news and more, subscribe to The Norman Transcript Smart Edition, or our print edition.